Skip to main content
image

The Best Tire Shop in Saint Augustine

Tires are the single most important safety feature on your car. They are the only thing that connects the car to the road, and life-saving technologies like anti-lock brakes and electronic stability control cannot do their job if the tires don't have a good grip on the pavement.

As the adage goes, nothing lasts forever. Car owners still need to replace their tires a few times or more throughout the life of a typical vehicle. Despite advances in longer-lasting tires, actual tread life will vary by car type, tire type (such as all season or high performance), driving aggressiveness, and even road and weather conditions. Proper maintenance and responsible driving can maximize the mileage in a set of tires.

Call Today! 904-819-6599 or stop by at 1585 Pinecrest St

We offer these services to help you prolong the life of your tires.

Tire Balancing
If your steering wheel shakes or your ride feels rough, your tires may be out of balance. Our techs use precision equipment to evenly distribute weight and eliminate vibration, ensuring a smoother and safer ride. Call us at 904-819-6599 if you have questions, or contact us so we can evaluate your tires.

Tire Inspection
Tires should be inspected regularly-ideally during oil changes or tire rotations. We check for tread wear, cracks, bulges, punctures, or foreign objects that could cause failure. Even small imperfections can evolve into dangerous situations.

Tire Repairs
Our tire experts inspect your tires to determine if they can be safely repaired or need replacing. We follow strict safety standards-if the tire can be plugged and patched properly, our certified technicians will handle the repair to get you safely back on the road. For punctures or sidewall damage beyond repair, we'll recommend the right replacement option.

Tire Rotation
Tire rotation evens out wear across all four tires, maximizing their lifespan and helping you avoid premature replacements. Generally, tire rotation should be done every 5,000 to 8,000 miles. Evans Automotive & Tire Center can help set up a schedule tailored to your vehicle and driving habits.

Used Tires
Need new tires on a budget? We offer carefully inspected used tires for a more affordable solution. Every tire is vetted for safety and performance-so you can hit the road with peace of mind.

We Carry Top Tire Brands
Tire quality matters. That's why Evans Automotive & Tire Center in Saint Augustine, FL carries trusted major brands built for performance, longevity, and safety. Whether you drive a compact car or manage a fleet, we'll help you choose the best tires for your needs.

Wheel Alignment Services
A proper wheel alignment adjusts your suspension and steering geometry to factory specs, ensuring even tire wear, better handling, and increased fuel efficiency. Misalignments can occur over time or after hitting potholes and curbs. For expert alignment services, schedule a visit to Evans Automotive & Tire Center.

Once a need for new tires is determined, it is necessary to identify the best tires for your vehicle and driving demands. Look for tires that do well in tests for braking, handling, and resistance to hydroplaning. Winter traction should also be considered, if applicable. Let tread wear, ride comfort, noise, and rolling resistance be tiebreakers. Trust the tire experts at Evans Automotive & Tire Center to help you choose the right tires for your vehicle.

We offer most major brands of tires. These are a few of our preferred brands.

Learn More About Which Tires Are Right For You

Contact Us Today!

Got questions? We've got answers! Drop us a line, give us a call, or even stop by. Our team is eager to help you with any auto repair needs you have. Let's get you back on the road safely and swiftly!

What Our Customers Are Saying

Evans Automotive And Tire Center Reviews

Had a great experience with Evans Automotive in St Augustine . I originally went to Hanania Jeep (huge mistake)in town, because Evans Automotive was closed for Christmas and I was desperate. Hanania quoted me $1300-1600 for ignition and new keys ( keys weren't needed). I felt very pressured there and left, and waited for Evans to reopen. Evans repaired my 2016 Jeep for $596. The service was excellent, with no pressure. They did only what was needed and no upsell. Evans stands out for their integrity, great service and high quality work. I highly recommend them to anyone needing reliable and affordable repairs. ( If they happen to be closed, just be patient because it's worth the wait :))

, 01/16/2026

Very honest and transparent, called and immediately was taken care of, gave me a free brake inspection and they put on my tires that I didn't buy through them and took care of a full brake service! Dropped off at 11:45 am on a very busy Monday and had my car ready before they closed. Very happy with the job they did and I will definitely be back.

, 01/13/2026

Quality service and great communication! Hard to find quality service with great communication and these guys are great at both! This is a business I trust and would highly recommend.

, 12/21/2025

Make em sing that song run run Rudolph Santa got make it to town in there head that song will be

, 12/13/2025

Decorative background image

Partners

  • ACDelco
  • AAA (American Automobile Association)
  • ASE (Automotive Service Excellence)
  • Jasper
  • ASA (Automotive Service Association)
  • BG Products
  • Gates